Trust The Phantom, phans. He knows that seven brides and seven brothers adds up to 14 phine actors, and that seven squared is 49. The title of this insightful review refers to the cast-to-stage ratio during TTC’s Seven Brides for Seven Brothers. The Phantom believes that it may have been an all-time high. Sure, there weren’t 49 people in the cast, but there wasn’t a whole stage there, either. Never before have we seen quite so many people jammed into such a small area as in this production’s throng scenes. The Phantom has heard of a distant past when, being eager (or desperate) to sell the occasional ticket, TTC put almost anyone on stage so as to pack in the relatives and friends of, and police officers pursuing, members of the cast. However, those hard times seem to be behind us. Take note, gynormous board of The Theater Company, you no longer have to cast “actors” with large supportive families in order to fill your theater. There are actually patrons who are not related to, or who work with, a cast member who attend your shows and come back time and time again. We have chatted with them in the lobby before the show. You have officially arrived, TTC, as a “entertainment venue” in the Brazos Valley. You are now at the point where you can hand pick your “talent,” reduce the size of your voluminous board and sit back and enjoy your hard earned success. Congratulations TTC, it’s all gravy from here.
(Well, except for anonymous bloggers. They’re like damn gnats, having actual opinions.) {That’s one of the problems with civil society these days. The damn Internets are uncontrollable. Curses, Internets!} [On the other hand, there is freedom of expression to consider here.] /Don’t be ridiculous, Phantom. Uniformity! Conformity! That’s what we need!\ <What? Who said that? Show yourself!>
Uh, oh. The Phantom is having another of those multiple personality moments. Much like the male lead in this show. But what’s that you say? You eager Phantomophiles may think that this prelude portends a pissy perusal of a particular production. But has The Phantom ever been predictable? This production was another TTC success, evidently selling well. (How, by the way, does the TTC Board determine whether a show will run two or three weekends? The Wilson Success Predetermination Machine [patent pending]? The Texas A&M football schedule? The configuration of the planets in the sky? The probability of suckiness minus number of children divided by the arabesque quotient of ballerinas aged eight from Suzanne’s School of Dance? It boggles the mind and sends The Phantom into a dance with numbers and geometry and angles and formulas. Some mysteries are too deep for his simple self. )
This was another show that was a stage version of a popular MGM movie musical (see “Singin’ in the Rain”). Does the movie go into the stage performance? Does the stage performance reference the film? Can you add songs to a song-heavy book without adding to running time? There is movie magic that just can’t be translated to the stage and there is stage magic that just can’t be translated to the big screen. A tricky proposition, but TTC has not recently shied away from “tricky” or “risky” or even “what the…!!! You are NOT serious.” Ever ballsy—and always looking for new ways to pack ‘em in—TTC took this show by the horns, bet the farm and came out in the black. Nicely played. (Applaud The Phantom, y’all, for his entertaining use of the mixed metaphor.) [Mrs. Wilson, The Phantom’s eighth-grade English teacher would. She taught him to write the goodest he could.] {But The Phantom, always conscious of the needs of his readers, wonders if a second parenthetical excursion might not be stretching the patience of his Phans.} /You know, it really is all about you, Phans. That’s why The Phantom posts his reviews in such a timely fashion, allowing you to use his wise guidance to decide whether or not to see a show.\ <Seriously, count on The Phantom.>
Where were we? Oh, right. The opening scene gave us Adam right at the start. Thank goodness. This guy is a remarkable singer who nails every single song sent his way. He’s easy on the eyes, too. Females young, old and everything in between all seemed a touch weak in the knees over this McDreamy Guy of the Musical (MGM). The Phantom is actually a little annoyed. Last time we saw MGM was across the pond in Camelot. He nailed that Brit-speak, at least in the first act. Thereafter, his accent disintegrated into a mush-mouthed impression of Sean Connery. Well, now we’re in Oregon Territory in the 1850s, and we have MGM hitting the western mountain man voice, making all the ladies swoon, even with the chauvinistic “Bless Your Beautiful Hide.” Here was our first opportunity to check out the acting and accent chops of our male lead. Good job. Great job. Good voice, good delivery. We really liked this guy. Lots of fire and sexiness and bravado. Good connection with his fellow performers. Act One: Number One. He was on top. Ranking? Top marks. 10 out of 10. A perfect score.
Say what? Phaithful readers have rarely seen The Phantom be so supportive. That’s because, with his new pharmaceutical regimen finally reaching its therapeutic dose, The Phantom is trying to be nice before he delivers just a wee bit of wise criticism. Act Two: Adam falls apart. He could have, but didn’t, trust the book. He could have, but didn’t, communicate measured amounts of wounded pride that would have left him a sympathetic character the audience could understand. Nope, he started yelling and he let his apparent anger creep over into misogynistic brutality. It was jarring and unattractive. For a psych guy, he was Abby Normal, and we thought he was going to pop a vein with all the angst-ridden screaming. Then, after we have decided that Adam was a macho cockroach at the peak of the sexist-spousal-abuse bell curve, he comes crashing down to deliver a tender and lovely reunion scene with Millie and the baby. It was sweet but unconvincing because we knew that no one could make that emotional change without Thorazine, Phenobarbital, Electro-therapy and a good rap on the back of the head. There were also moments of mush-mouthedness in which MGM could not be understood. Unfortunately, we suspect they were sometimes important lines, and had we not already been familiar with the story we could have found ourselves in a quadrilateral quandary. Something about a ??? being closed for the ??? by an ??? Add it all up, and Adam was excellent in the first half and oddly overwrought in the second. We hope his dissertation committee makes him rewrite that second section and that he will continue to entertain us at TTC.
Speaking of advisers, we were left scratching our head at two choices made by the director of the show. The first was the decision to pack the entire horde, or, ah, cast, on stage for big dance numbers. No good. They were too crowded on half a stage, unpleasantly so. The second was the decision to allow Adam to go the apoplexy route and become such a disreputable abuser-in-training. Direct them, please. Rein in your flock when their choices don’t fit the show.
There was only one cringe-worthy performance in the show and it was small, practically miniscule and fractional. But it was certainly less than prime, and this wouldn’t be TWOP if The Phantom failed to mention it. (Quick, Phans, who would you nominate for this unfortunate recognition?) Sorry, the prize goes to the hapless Mrs. Bixby, who reminded us of the over-emoting Catherine O’Hara character (Sheila Albertson) in Waiting for Guffman. True, she wasn’t miked but there still was that je ne sais quoi timbre to her delivery that had us on the brink of high school musical flashbacks, and we certainly don’t ever, ever, ever want to go back there. No, no, no, not the Clayton Williams High School Fightin’ Prairie Dog Senior Class Production of “To Kill A Mockingbird: The Musical.” Oh, the humanity.
We met Millie, our intrepid, sassy and just the right size heroine. Millie is a familiar face to TTC but she’s all growed up now. We’ve heard all about her summer in Palo Duro and her time down in Brenham, and she can only be quietly applauded for determined self-promotion. That’s what it takes, darling. You go, girl. She had a nice voice; she proved that she is not a true soprano, but she was musical-theater-good with a perky stage presence, and we think she did a nice job as Millie. She played a little young but that is not such a terrible problem to have—and in all fairness the other brides were younger still, so it went well overall. And she had nice chemistry with Adam. Not as sizzlin’ as we would have liked but it wasn’t forced either. We think that with experience and maturity this young lady will do very well indeed. It was a solo-heavy production and Millie had the stamina and singing chops to last till the very end, and that in itself is praiseworthy. Clap, clap, young Millie. Her song with the newly introduced brides was lovely and it did a fair amount of exposition and foreshadowing to propel this movie musical into a stage production.
The brides were perky and pretty, with their own sizable squeal quotient. No one stood out, all numbers being equal, and it was the brothers who stole the show by a factor of five. The Phantom has correctly reported on several occasions that the TTC women were stronger than the men, but this time he was pleasantly surprised. The brothers all did a very good job. Fight scenes are tough to pull off without, ironically, anyone getting hurt, and we think and hope that no one did get hurt. It looked possible. Benjamin was great although he started off too mean (not grouchy, Benjamin, mean), but he ended the show strong with a clean solo in the wintertime song. Caleb was brawny. Daniel was athletic. Ephraim was skinny. Gideon was young. So you get my point. The brothers were a true ensemble. They had the best songs, and the physicality and bravado they employed in their dance numbers definitely gets a Phantom clap, clap. But there was one of them who deserves the largest piece of pi. Gideon was a stand-up, high numbered, call-out, it-factor star. Great job, Gideon. You shined when you should and blended when you should. You were both a support and a leader. Russ Tamblyn would have been pleased.
The choreography was some of the best we have seen all year. Even the gratuitous ballet sequences were good, but The Phantom, always the sage, did have one small complaint. We realize that the show seemed to be a bit “brother-centric” but we feel that the Alvin Ailey-inspired dance routine that the brides did alongside the brothers in the “We’ve Gotta Make it Through the Winter” number was gratuitous and distracting and needless and odd. It was unnecessary, too. Oh, and misplaced. It was even gratuitous and distracting. The number would have been stronger without the women. And speaking of fairness in song distribution, what the heck happened to “June Bride” which was a wonderful song in the movie and highlighted the hot and statuesque Julie Newmar before she became the hot and statuesque CatWoman who fueled so many pubescent fantasies in that shiny vinyl form-fitting one-piece? (The Phantom will take a moment here. Oh yes. Now, shall we continue?)
The lighting was dim and disjointed but did not distract too terribly much from the show. The set was not a particular standout in this production and only seemed to get in the way of itself. This bears commenting because TTC (and frankly all the Valley set people) have done outstanding jobs this year. But when you cut the stage in half from stage-left to stage-right and then pack it full of humanity and ask them all to dance, [Everybody dance-Corky St. Clair] you are just asking for trouble. The choreographer must have used a bullhorn to be heard, putting together the throng scenes. Less is more in many cases, TTC. The Phantom knows that advice defies mathematical reason, but it makes so much emotional sense. The poor patron too often did not know where to look.
Did no one know that “avalanche” means snow, and snow means winter? The occasional jacket might have been a helpful prop.
But fret not, TTC, The Phantom was entertained. The men were great, the women were phine, and, except for the misogyny-overkill, the whole horde did a very fine job with this show. Despite the crowds. And we ain’t talking about the audience.
Other than that, it was great.
The Phantom